Are indented scars helped by silicone sheets? or just scars of the raised/keloid type?

Hello to all of you:) So, by accident, I got a small piece of flesh removed when someone scraped my cheek. I’ve been using Vaseline to keep it wet for the past five days, almost nonstop. Thankfully, it appears to be mending nicely! What comes next is what I want to know. According to what I’ve read, silicone sheets should be used once the wound heals. However, my scar might be atrophic, or indented, and I’ve read that silicone sheets are only effective on elevated scars. Is there anyone with any knowledge?

1 Like

Silicone sheets help raised or keloid scars but aren’t effective for indented scars. For indented scars, low-dose retinol (0.1%) can improve their appearance by boosting collagen turnover. It’s important to remember that scars can take years to fully form, so early treatment can aid the healing process.

2 Likes

I used mederma and silicone scar sheets to treat a 1-inch cut that I had on my forehead due to an accident. I should only use the scar sheets for a month or two, my dermatologist advised. On January 3, the accident will have been a year ago, and the scar has almost completely healed. There is no longer any redness, and the scar tissue is largely flat and lustrous in comparison to the surrounding skin. I’m pleased with how it went out, though I’m not sure how much of that is because of the scar sheets or mederma.

I had a similar situation where I accidentally injured my skin and was concerned about scarring. I also used Vaseline to keep the wound moist, which helped with healing. Once the wound healed, I learned that silicone sheets are typically recommended for raised scars, but they might not be as effective for atrophic or indented scars. From my experience, for atrophic scars, options like silicone gel, dermarolling, or treatments like chemical peels might be more effective. It’s a good idea to consult with a dermatologist to get personalized advice and to explore treatments that can help improve the appearance of atrophic scars.