Does witch hazel expire?-Why has it suddenly become so controversial?

I’ve noticed a recent surge in criticism of witch hazel, which is surprising given its popularity and positive feedback in recent years, especially brands like Thayer’s. Scrolling through Twitter, it seems like everyone is now labeling it as the worst thing ever. I’m wondering if this is just another case of an echo chamber effect, or if I should be worried about using it. How much do beauty gurus influence your skincare routine?

1 Like

"It’s widely considered that because witch hazel has “astringent” characteristics, it can “dry up” pimples. However, acne does not occur while the skin is wet, thus drying it with astringent chemicals will not help. In reality, the irritation induced by witch hazel might exacerbate pimples. Paula’s favourite ingredient library stuff.

Imo, witch hazel started as a huge fad among teenagers attempting to dry out their oils, and then everyone decided it was the best thing ever. However, even though it was “natural” and “alcohol-free,” it did a lot of damage to my skin. I suppose it has its uses, but I personally believe it is not suitable for everyone, which is why I do not believe it should be recommended.

Witch hazel does have an expiration date, which you can usually find on the bottle. Over time, its effectiveness can decrease, and it might not work as well or could potentially irritate your skin if it’s past its prime. As for the controversy, it’s worth noting that opinions can shift quickly in the beauty world, often influenced by new research or personal experiences shared online. It’s always a good idea to stay informed and see what works best for your skin, rather than relying solely on trends or social media buzz.

Witch hazel can be drying, so it might not suit all skin types. Consider your skin type and look for products with added moisturizers. If unsure, patch test first.