Which all-natural deodorant is the best that you've tried?

One that didn’t make you a sweaty and onion-smelling mess of a person in a couple of hours, preferably.

Thanks!

Crystal rock salt deodorant. But I absolutely must shower every day or it won’t work. You can’t throw it on a stinky armpit like some of the fragrance-filled sticks and have it deodorize you. Gotta get in before the bacteria starts to grow, that’s why it works.

A tiny company in New Brunswick, Canada makes the best I’ve tried, though it’s pricey: Super Deodorant. It is a paste (natural clay base) that comes in a little tin, not unlike lipgloss. A little dab once a day, and eventually every other day. I used roll-on salt/crystal deodorants for 20 years with great success & then my body chemistry changed and I became that “onion mess” for a while. Not anymore!

I really like Lumé. Only one that worked for me

I loved Lume for about two years but the last batch I ordered had changed: the solid/stick is now WAY softer and just goes to mush, and it doesn’t control odor like it used to. I’m bummed. Edit: a word

I wish Lume worked for me :frowning: I tried the toasted coconut scent and it smells like movie popcorn, and after wearing it for a day I smelled like popcorn AND b.o.

I think natural deodorant is a total scam. There’s no evidence that antiperspirant is bad for us. It’s pseudoscience. The natural deodorants just don’t work

Yes, and as someone who doesn’t use “natural” deodorant but has friends who swear by it… yeah, those friends still smell. They are just used to it.

A ton of people in my family are allergic to the aluminum in antiperspirants…natural deodorant is our only option. It’s so much better now than it was years ago when the only options were arm and hammer or the crystal. Many do work for deodorizing, just not as antiperspirants.